NO MEN ARE FOREIGN
-James Kirkup
- SUMMARY
The poem 'No Men are Foreign’ is all about human beings. Also, it tells that all human beings who live on this earth are brothers and are the same. Moreover, we all have the same kind of body and we all need sun, air, water, and clothes to cover us. We all walk the land and feed ourselves with the harvest of this earth. Upon death, people will bury us in this same land. In addition, we all do work and sleep and wake up, love and want to be loved in return for others. But we (human beings) hate each other and because of this, we live on by hating and fighting with one another. Further, it is humans who pollute the environment by taking into consideration its bad impact on other people.
- Stanza based explanation
Stanza 1
In the first line the poet says that no men are strange, and no country is foreign. So, he is attempting to remove the borders from the Earth which have been erected to separate different countries. Then only no country will be foreign. We will feel every country as our own land when there will be no borders, everyone will be free to move around. The poet wants to say that the entire Earth is one and all the people who live on this Earth belong to one human race. Then he says that inside the uniforms worn by soldiers of different countries, the human being is the same. God has made all of us in a similar way. All breathe in the same way. Then he says that all the soldiers are our brothers – we all walk upon the same ‘Mother Earth’ and upon our death, shall lie in the grave on the same Earth.
Stanza 2
‘They’ refers to those people who belong to other countries. We call them foreigners and discriminate
against them and fight with them also. The poet says that nature has given all the bounties to all people
also just like he has given to us. Everyone gets sunlight, air and water in equal measure which means that
God does not differentiate between people from different countries. We all do farming during the time of
peace, when there is no war. We live a relaxed life and eat the things given to us by nature. Further, he
adds that the way we starve during wars and winter time is the same for those belonging to other
countries. They don't even get food at that time. So, he wants to say that foreigners who belong to
another country and we, both are the same. And then the poet says that even though their hands are the
same as ours, they work very hard just like we do. He is giving all these examples to convey to the reader
that there is no difference in us and the people belonging to another country.
Stanza 3
The poet asks the reader to remember it. He says that we should keep in mind that the people of another
country, whom we think to be our enemies, have been bestowed by God with similar appearance like us.
God has given them eyes like ours which open when awake and close when we are asleep. Similarly, he
has given them strength which we can win through love. Then he says that in every country, in every land
there is one common thing, that is life. Life means all the things that are living. And if we can recognize
them and if we can understand their feelings and realize that they are like us, then there will be no fights
or wars between us.
Stanza 4
The poet says that we should remember that whenever someone tells us to hate a person from another country, to think of him as our enemy, and whenever we think of someone to be our enemy, then we deprive ourselves, we cheat ourselves, and we condemn ourselves. He says that we should stay away from such negativity. We should not consider anyone to be our enemy. During a war, both the parties must bear the loss. And that is why the poet says that war is not in our favour. He says that whenever we pick any weapon against someone, we should remember one thing that no one is our enemy.
Stanza 5
We should keep in mind that whenever we pick weapons against any person, we make the Earth dirty because weapons kill people and their bodies which fall on the Earth make it dirty. Whenever war happens, it leads to a lot of bloodshed, fire and death. These dead bodies accumulate on the Earth and make it impure. The fire of war which erupts, the smoke which comes out, the dust which fills the air – it is so dirty that it pollutes and outrages the purity of the air. With all these things the poet wants to give us a message that we should not indulge in war. Finally, he ends the poem by writing the first line in reverse and saying that Remember, no men are foreign, and no countries are strange.
Extract Based questions (Solved)
Q1.It is the human earth that we defile. Our hells of fire and dust outrage the innocence Of air that is everywhere our own, Remember, no men are foreign, and no countries strange.
(a) What do you understand by ‘human earth?’
Answer: Human earth refers to the earth on which human beings live and that is full of human feelings and human values of love and brotherhood.
(b) Explain: hells of fire and dust?
Answer: The hells of fire and dust are the fire and dust caused by wars between countries.
(c) How is the innocence of air outraged?
Answer: Fire and dust caused by wars make the air impure.
(d) How does the poet bring out the idea that men are not strangers to one another?
Answer: The poet specifies that just like us they wake and sleep and respond to love. Even if we look different on the exterior we all can recognise and understand the universal language of love and brotherhood.
Q2.Let us remember, whenever we are told To hate our brothers, it is ourselves That we shall dispossess, betray, condemn. Remember, we who take arms against each other
(a) Who is the narrator of the poem? To whom is the poem addressed?
Answer: The poem appears to have an omniscient narrator and is addressed to all mankind.
(b) Who tells us to hate our brothers?
Answer: Our leaders tell us to hate our brothers who belong to another country or a different religious, social or political group.
(c) Why do they tell us to hate our brothers?
Answer: They tell us to hate our brothers for their own personal gains.
(d) Should we believe those who tell us to hate our brothers? Why/why not?
Answer: We should not become puppets in the hands of those who incite us to hatred. If we fight with our brothers, we condemn ourselves too.
Extract based questions (Unsolved)
Q1. Remember, no men are strange, no countries foreign Beneath all uniforms, a single body breathes Like ours: the land our brothers walk upon Is earth like this, in which we all shall lie.
(a) Who does the poet address in the poem? Name the poetic device used in line 1.
(b) What does the word “uniform” mean?
(c) What breathes beneath all uniforms?
(d) What is the irony in uniform?
Q2.They, too, aware of sun and air and water, Are fed by peaceful harvests, by war’s long winter starv’d. Their hands are ours, and in their lines we read A labour not different from our own.
(a) Whom does ‘they’ refer to?
(b) What is the significance of the word “too”?
(c) What does the poet mean by ‘peaceful harvests’?
(d) What is the message of the poem?
Short answer type questions (Solved)
Q1.How does the poet prove that there are no foreign countries?
Answer: Everyone shares the same sun, earth and air. They have the same body structure and its functioning elements. So there should be no biased attitude towards anyone.
Q2. What is meant by uniforms? What is there beneath all uniforms?
Answer:The word “uniform” refers to the distinctive clothing worn by members of the same organization or body or by children attending certain schools. In this poem, the poet uses “uniforms” to mean both the uniforms worn by soldiers and the varied traditional dresses belonging to different cultures and civilisations of the world, or the different clothes that symbolise who the wearers are. Beneath all uniforms lies the same human body. How can we be one people even though we belong to different nations?
Q3.How are all the people of the world brothers?
Answer:All human beings are similar in structure as we are all flesh and blood. We walk on the same land as long as we are alive and will be buried in the same earth when we die. We also use the same sun, air and water.
Q4.How can we be one people though we belong to different nations?
Answer: Even if we belong to different nations, we can be one people because we all have the same body and we live and die on the same planet. All of us enjoy the same sun, air and water.
Q5.State briefly the theme of the poem.
Answer: The theme of the poem is one of globalisation, universal brotherhood and the renunciation of war. The world is one big family, no one is a stranger: no one is different; we all need and want the same things. Hence, waging wars against our brothers does not make sense.
Short answer type questions (Unsolved)
Q1.How can we be one people though we belong to different nations?
Q2.What are peaceful harvests? What do the peaceful harvests symbolise?
Q3.What does the poet mean when he says “by war’s long winter starv’d”?
Q4. What does the poet want to emphasize by beginning and ending the poem with the same line?
Q5. How does air remind us of our sharing the earth? How is air innocent?
Long answer type questions (Solved)
Q1. How are all men our brothers?
Answer: All men are our brothers. No human beings are strange or unfamiliar. Underneath the external trappings of different cultures or civilisations or any colour of any soldier’s uniform belonging to any nation, all human beings are the same. All men walk upon the same earth and one day are laid to rest in their graves under the same earth. Each and every human being is nourished by the same sun, breathes the same air and drinks the same water to survive. All human beings have eyes that wake or sleep. In every land, there is a common life. Love is paramount everywhere that wins the heart. When we hate others, fight with them, raise arms against them, it is ourselves that we shall dispossess, betray and condemn. Thus, despite different living conditions, all human beings are one in spirit.
Q2.In the poem “No Men Are Foreign” explain the poet’s use of the word 'uniform'.
Answer: The literal meaning of “uniform” is a dress, costume or identification code that is similar to a group or organisation. The poet, here, uses the word “uniform” metaphorically to denote the universal brotherhood of man. On the other hand, uniforms are necessary especially during war in order to identify oneself as belonging to that country so as not to kill or harm its own people. In the wearing of their country’s uniform, they contradict the meaning of the word since they are set apart and identified as different—the enemy. Thus, James Kirkup points out the irony in the word uniform. This contradiction is based on the uniformity of man, as the poet suggests that all men are uniform themselves in the sense that they are “aware of sun and air and water” and they share humanity, and different uniforms identifying the wearers as being different from each other.
Long answer type questions (Unsolved)
Q1.”Wars have always brought total ruin in this world,yet they are fought repeatedly”. Elaborate.
Q2.How does the poem justify that people in all countries of the world are essentially the same?
Q3.How according to the poet, the human earth is ‘defiled’ and the innocence of air ‘outraged’?
No comments:
Post a Comment